Getting Scooped

Success in academic medicine is largely measured by publications. In fact, we live by the code: Publish or Perish. This means that you either show your abilities in research by publishing articles in peer-reviewed journals or else you will be deemed unproductive, incompetent, and ultimately irrelevant in the eyes of your colleagues.

There is TREMENDOUS pressure to publish. Not only are you concerned that about showing some productivity (it can be years between publications), but you will also be intimately worried about the possibility of someone beating you to the punch and publishing the same findings first. Researchers call this "getting scooped." This is bad news because it means your research project has just gone from being cutting-edge to yesterday's news. Novelty is lost and it looks like the other guys thought of it first (regardless if you did or not), so they can then claim all the credit.

It may seem uncommon, given the immensity of science, that two or more groups would be working on the exact same research project at the exact same time. Heck, it might even seem counterproductive for research dollars to be spent investigating the same thing. [Note: I'll save the debate about competition in science for another post.] However, it actually happens all the time. Just think of Elisha Gray. Who is Elisha Gray? Exactly. He's the guy that got scooped by Alexander Graham Bell in inventing the telephone. Bell made it to the patent office only a few hours before Gray. Point of the story: Don't be like Gray, don't get scooped. Of course, this means living in perpetual fear whenever you start a project because you are worried about whether someone will have already started on it and thus have a head start on you. Or, there are always those people out there who work day and night, sacrificing body and soul, in pursuit of scooping other people (aka Gunners).

Although most academians claim to be collegial, I know few who are entirely open with their ideas and data, simply because of the possibility of being scooped. There will always be the eager grad student/post-doc/PI sniffing around for the latest great idea to steal and publish without recognizing the origin (unless of course she praises himself for her ingenuity). As an aspiring researcher, you should be mindful of this fact because you don't want to share more information than you want to, but you still want to maintain collaborations. I'll admit its a tricky balancing act that will take some time to learn and you'll probably get burned a few times before you know when to pipe-up.